The Evolutionary Roots of Personality Differences: Keirsey vs. Jung

While Carl Jung's groundbreaking work in psychology serves as a fundamental framework for understanding human behavior, David Keirsey's ethological theories add a fascinating lens to comprehending the nuances of personality. This article delves into the differences between Keirsey's temperaments and Jung's personality types, drawing parallels to our evolved survival strategies rooted in ancestral subsistence patterns.

Keirsey's Temperaments: Beyond Jungian Types

Keirsey, building upon Jung's theories, identified four fundamental temperaments based on our evolved survival strategies. Each temperament is associated with a specific pattern of behavior and a set of adaptive stigmas. Let’s explore these differences and their implications on modern political and social dynamics.

Conservatives and Liberals: A Tale of Patriotic Leavers and Global Ex-pats

Have you ever noticed that liberals often want to leave a country when conservative leaders like Donald Trump take office, while no conservative feels the same about a liberal leader like Barack Obama? This phenomenon arises from our deep-seated ancestral tendencies towards survival.

Conservatives, characterized by their high patriotism and strong attachment to their communities, tend to see a threat to their way of life. Conversely, liberals, interested in global cultures and often spending time abroad, are more flexible and open to new experiences. These contrasting tendencies reflect the splitting and merging survival strategies of hunter-gatherers and pastoralists, respectively.

The Survival Strategies of Hunter-Gatherers and Pastoralists

Hunter-gatherers employ a 'splitting and merging' strategy, splitting off from groups in response to scarce resources and merging with local groups when new opportunities arise. This approach ensures survival in unpredictable environments. In contrast, pastoralists adopt a more aggressive 'offensive' strategy, raiding neighboring tribes in times of resource scarcity.

The 'defensive' strategy seen in farmers reflects a settled lifestyle, where conflicts are managed through walls and alliances. This reflects the prosocial tendencies of gatherers and the explorative nature of pastoralists. Each strategy has its own set of adaptive behaviors, influencing modern political and social orientations.

Mapping Keirsey's Temperaments onto Jungian Types

To better understand the differences between Keirsey's temperaments and Jung's personality types, we can draw parallels to familiar constructs:

Hunters (Extraverted Sensing, Intuitive Observers) can be seen as Artisans or Explorers in the DISC system. They are often rebels like Mao and Stalin. Gatherers (Introverted Sensing, IntuitiveThinkers) correspond to Idealists, Diplomats, and Inspirators. They are often peacemakers, religious leaders, or religious figures like Gandhi, Martin Luther King Jr., and Pope Francis. Pastoralists (Extraverted Sensing, Intuitive Adventurers) align with Artisans, Dominances, and Prospector, embodying artists, entertainers, and explorers such as Eric Clapton, Lionel Messi, Donald Trump, and Christopher Columbus. Farmers (Introverted Sensing, Introverted Thinkers) map onto Guardians, often found in politics like Angela Merkel and Mitt Romney.

Implications for Modern Society

The evolution of these survival strategies significantly influences our modern political orientations. Hunter-gatherers embody the most liberal/libertarian tendencies, while farmers represent the most conservative. This explains why liberals feel the urge to leave a country when illiberal leaders are elected, and why conservatives feel the need to build walls when threatened.

Understanding these underlying tendencies can provide valuable insights into political behaviors and social dynamics. For instance, the 2016 US presidential election, with Donald Trump's victory, can be seen as a reflection of the aggressive pastoralist survival strategy in a time of perceived economic uncertainty.

Further Reading: For more detailed insights, please check out my latest book.