New Zealanders’ Perspective: Why We Are Not as Pro-American as We Once Were

Every country, and every person, has unique perspectives on the world, influenced by a myriad of factors. This article delves into the evolving relationship between New Zealand and the United States, particularly from the viewpoint of a New Zealander named Ian, whose thoughts will enlighten readers about the reasons behind the shift in New Zealand's attitude towards its neighbor and former ally.

Understanding the Shift in New Zealand’s Stance

As a 61-year-old Australian, a long-standing friend of the United States, Ian still holds a deep admiration for the nation. However, over the past few decades, New Zealanders have become more self-reliant and less inclined to emulate the American lifestyle. This shift in perspective is not because New Zealanders have lost respect for America, but rather because they have evolved into a more independent nation with their own values and priorities.

Although the United States remains a global superpower, New Zealanders have witnessed the country’s flaws and contradictions, leading to a more critical view. This is not to suggest that New Zealanders are fundamentally against the United States, but rather that New Zealanders are more focused on aligning with their own interests and principles.

Key Milestones in Relations

After World War II, New Zealand and the United States shared a strong alliance. The US played a crucial role in freeing the Pacific and established close ties with Australia. New Zealand was no stranger to this camaraderie, having stood firmly beside the US during the conflict by holding the line against Japan and offering essential support to the Pacific fleet.

Furthermore, both nations were instrumental in the formation of the United Nations and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Many New Zealanders held the US up as an exemplar of a just society, cherishing the ideal of civic engagement exemplified during President Kennedy's tenure. His assassination was a profound national tragedy that moved many people to tears.

Challenges and Concerns

Today, New Zealanders observe that the US, while still a formidable nation, has faced significant internal and external challenges. The nation has been portrayed as an entity that often struggles with its own institutions and is increasingly ruled by a powerful oligarchy of vested interests. This is a stark contrast to the perceptions of the past, when New Zealanders admired the American system and the values it upheld.

Questions and criticisms from New Zealanders arise due to several American policies, including:

The erosion of the social safety net, which the US had championed post-war and helped foster peace and prosperity across the nation. The lack of affordable healthcare, leading to inadequate medical care for citizens. The disparity in the standard of living for working people, who often rely on unemployment benefits rather than a livable wage. The perceived decline in women's status and the increasing backlash against democratic processes. Funding crises in government, leading to a state of constant political turmoil. The treatment of the head of state as being above the law, a practice reminiscent of a monarchy and in contrast to New Zealand's parliamentary democracy.

These factors have contributed to a more nuanced and critical view of the United States from New Zealanders, but it is important to note that it does not indicate a complete rejection of American principles or values.

Conclusion

While New Zealand maintains strong ties with the United States, the dynamic between the two nations has evolved over time. New Zealanders recognize the strength and resilience of their neighbor but also believe in the importance of standing by their own values and interests. This relationship, marked by mutual respect and dialogue, is essential for both nations as they navigate the complex landscape of global affairs.