ICWA vs Chartered Accountant: Salary Disparity and Future Outlook
In the realm of accounting, the career paths and salary expectations of an ICWA (Indian Cost and Works Accountant) and a Chartered Accountant (CA) diverge significantly, often reflecting their perceived importance and relevance in the evolving business world.
Initial Earnings and Career Trajectory
Let's consider the starting salaries of these two professions to ascertain their initial earning potential. An ICWA, typically, earns around Rs. 6 lakhs annually, often remaining in the same position for life. This stagnant career path, juxtaposed with the geographical and cultural bias within the ICWAI institute, can lead to economic limitations and a lack of upward mobility.
Contrastingly, a Chartered Accountant starts off with a job, and within a period of 15 years, often rises to become a Chief Financial Officer (CFO). This coveted position can yield an impressive salary of Rs. 80 lakhs to Rs. 1 crore. The earning potential of a CA is not just monetary; it also includes the possibility of significant advancement within the corporate hierarchy.
Long-Term Consequences and Career Advancement
The lasting impacts of these respective career paths become even more evident as professionals age. Annual job changes for CAs and the opportunity to climb the corporate ladder provide a pathway for substantial salary increases and a fulfilling career. However, for ICWAs, the picture is starkly different. Reports from cost conventions organized by the ICWAI show a disheartening scene of former cost accountants transformed into beggars. The public appearance of these individuals, often found in areas like mosques and temples, starkly illustrates the personal and professional struggles they face.
The ICWAI institute, located in Kolkata since its inception, has remained largely unresponsive to the modern needs of the profession. Despite the advancements brought about by artificial intelligence and automation, the ICWAI has failed to evolve its curriculum or professional standards. This stagnation has led to a decreasing relevance of the ICWA profession in the modern job market. As more industries adopt automated systems, the role of cost accountants becomes increasingly obsolete.
Role of Automation in the Accountancy Sector
Modern technology has revolutionized the way accounting and finance are handled. Systems now provide rapid and accurate calculations of things like standard costing and actual costing. This means that manual processes, which were once essential for cost accountants, are now unnecessary. Furthermore, cost audit, a requirement for certain industries, is becoming less mandatory, and many businesses are seeking exemptions from it. This trend further diminishes the importance of cost accountants in the industry.
GG.
The job outlook for cost accountants is bleak. In many organizations, they are relegated to administrative tasks with a salary of around Rs. 50k per month, a figure that seldom increases due to the minimal value added to the organization. While some may carry impressive titles on their LinkedIn profiles, their actual roles are often limited to administrative duties, with little to no impact on the organization's financial health.
In conclusion, the profession of ICWA and its relevance in the current business landscape must be critically examined. The stagnation and lack of modernization within the ICWAI institute have contributed to the diminishing importance of the ICWA role. It is high time for a radical change, and the dissolution of the institute may be necessary to pave the way for more dynamic and relevant accounting practices in the future.